The plaintiff further argued that the language was ambiguous and should be construed against the defendant, who was the drafter. The doctrine of contra proferentem construing ambiguous agreements. Without his commitment to continuing legal education, this publication would not be possible. Ambiguous lease agreement rightfully construed against. Agreement not construed against drafter sample clauses. In addition, defendant drafted the agreement and the same should be construed against the drafter. This agreement has been negotiated and prepared by seller and purchaser and their respective attorneys and, should any provision of this agreement require judicial interpretation, the court interpreting or construing such provision shall not apply the rule of construction that a document is to be construed more strictly against one party. Thus, the general rule is that ambiguities in the drafting of contracts are construed against the drafter. If contract is ambiguous, then it will be construed against drafter. Ken adams tilts at windmills again about representations and. In opposing the defendants rule 12b6 motion to dismiss, the plaintiff argued below that the forum selection clause was not exclusive. This is particularly important if you draft the contract because ambiguities in a contract are typically construed against the drafter.
Model clauses and agreements are reproduced on a cdrom accompanying the book, allowing. Oct 10, 2012 where this occurs, it is not necessarily true that the ambiguity will be construed against the drafter of the contract. Not to be construed against the drafter sample clauses. The party that drafted the document created ambiguity and errors. If this formidable hurdle is overcome, the courts will first turn to a host of rules pertaining to contract interpretation which can fill up entire chapters in legal texts. Any ambiguity in insurance contract must be interpreted against drafting party and in favor of insured. A cursory look at california waiver law sportwaiver. Supreme court rules that an ambiguous arbitration agreement does not provide a basis for class.
This agreement shall be governed by and construed in accordance with the laws of the state of texas, without regard to conflict of laws principles thereof. This agreement including this schedule, credit support annex, paragraph to the credit support annex, any confirmation, or any other amendment hereto shall not be construed against the drafter thereof, and the rule of contract construction requiring a contract to be construed against the drafter thereof is expressly. What california code states that the ambiguity will be construed against the drafter of the document. When a term is ambiguous, a crystal ball matter, the ambiguity should be construed against the draftsman. The contract may explicitly provide that terms will not be construed against either party for example in negotiated agreements such as mergers, vc, so on or the facts may indicate a negotiated agreement where both parties were represented by counsel. The parties acknowledge that no provision of this agreement will be interpreted in favor of, or against, any of the parties hereto because any such party or its counsel participated in the drafting thereof or because any such provision is inconsistent with any prior draft hereof or thereof. This agreement shall be binding upon the parties and upon their respective heirs, executors, administrators, legal representatives and assigns. Dd 1228 should ambiguity run against drafter in commercial. Its unfortunate that ken, who has a national following, makes such a misguided proposal. The principle of contra proferentem is a legal doctrine of contractual interpretation providing that ambiguous or conflicting terms within a contract should, generally, be construed against the party that drafted or proffered meaning put forward the agreement or demanded inclusion of the.
It is a basic principle of contract interpretation that ambiguous terms of a contract are construed against the drafter. Miller v boyanski 2009 new york other courts decisions. Construing the contract against the drafter lambert law. Although there are several drafting presumptions affecting commercial leases, one is particularly unique. At the simplest level, the views have been contrasted as being either classical or modern, static or. You should seek legal advice, most notably from this office, before resting your legal case on any hope that your desired rendition of your contract will prevail based upon that legal maxim. Scotus finds californias contract interpretation skills.
When that occurs, the interpretation least favorable to the drafter if that is what the other party is seeking will be held to control. Orsinger board certified in family law and civil appellate law texas board of legal specialization i. If an owner drafts the general contractor agreement and the contractor wants to argue that the language should be construed against the owner, as drafter, the contractor has to show that the phrase at issue is ambiguous. In entering into this agreement, each party is relying on any statements of fact made in this agreement by the other party. Stated otherwise, if an ambiguous term exists in the contract, courts should generally construe the term against the contracts drafter, unless the drafter presents persuasive extrinsic evidence that the parties intended a contrary result. The parties hereto have participated jointly in the negotiation and drafting of this agreement and, in the event an ambiguity or question of intent or interpretation arises, this agreement shall be construed as jointly drafted by the parties hereto and no presumption or burden of proof shall arise favoring or disfavoring any party by virtue of the authorship of any provision of this agreement. However, construing a contract against the drafter to resolve ambiguous contract language called the rule of contra proferentem is applicable only if the intent of the parties cannot be discerned through the use of all conventional rules of interpretation, including. The reasoning behind this rule is to encourage the drafter of a contract to be as. Ken goes on to recommend that drafters expressly concede reliance. The court found the doctrine does not apply in this case, because the phrase is not ambiguous, and in any case using the doctrine here was stretching it too far. This designation can be significant in a contract dispute.
An agreement, read as a whole, must clearly notify the prospective releaser or indemnitor of the effect of signing the agreement. Therefore, because it could be construed to have more than one reasonable interpretation, it is ambiguous. May 01, 2015 if contract is ambiguous, then it will be construed against drafter. The existence of this interpretation principle is well established. I am grateful to john mihail, ralf poscher and especially lawrence solum for helpful comments on earlier drafts. Each party has participated in negotiating and drafting this agreement, so if an ambiguity or a question of intent or interpretation arises, this agreement is to be construed as if the parties had drafted it jointly, as opposed to being construed against a party because it was responsible for drafting one or more provisions of this agreement. Agreement between builder and broker for selling the flats to be constructed. First, the trial court clearly erred in finding that defendant was the drafter of the addendum. According to the court, the insurer has a duty to draft clear and unambiguous terms and is bound by the language it drafts. The defendant filed a motion to dismiss, which was allowed by the superior court. Understanding the rule that ambiguity goes against the party that drafted the contract. How a contract is construed modern rules of construction. In a practical sense, the person that caused the uncertainty to exist is the person that drafted the agreement. If you write an agreement, then you have control over the language.
The guide to new jersey contract law was conceived and developed by clark alpert, esq. Please provide the ccp andor the case law that shows that i have some recourse against the drafter of the document who created the ambiguity. Generally, the language of a contract is to be construed against its drafter. As any ambiguity introduced by the second sentence of that provision must be construed against the insurer as drafter of the policy see essex ins. Judge plagers concurring opinion focuses on the intentional ambiguity inserted into the claims by 3m. The restatement second of contracts states that an agreement susceptible to more than one interpretation should be construed against the party who drafted the language. If its your fault that the language can be construed in different ways, then its only fair that you bear the burden of that ambiguity. The trial court found that the agreement was ambiguous, determined that the ambiguity should be construed against the drafter of the contract kroger, and entered judgment in favor of the employee. Even if the court determined that the aicall cleaning indemnification provision was ambiguous, it would be construed against aic as the indemnitee and drafter of the agreement. Generally, ambiguities are construed against the drafter of the instrument. The rule of construction that any ambiguity in an agreement be construed against the drafter of such agreement shall not apply to this agreement. Judge plager argues that courts should begin to apply the contract doctrine of contra proferentem and construe ambiguous terms against the. Apr 24, 2011 as any ambiguity introduced by the second sentence of that provision must be construed against the insurer as drafter of the policy see essex ins.
Moreover, dcg admits that it drafted the employment agreement. Based on the foregoing, the parties agree that any rules of construction requiring that a contract be construed against the drafter shall not be applied in interpreting this agreement. If a provision is susceptible to more than one reasonable interpretation. Certainly i agree with him that, if the substance of a statement amounts to a warranty, then the statement should be enforced as such, even though the drafter didnt use the actual word warrant or warranty. The most interesting opinion of the four is judge plagers concurring opinion that focuses on the intentional ambiguity inserted into the claims by 3m. The uniform commercial code the basic structure book icon. Deal struck is a book that can save lawyers a lot of agony, and misfortune. This agreement creates a legal relationship of rights and duties on the parties and. Florida clarifies that extrinsic evidence may not be used. Ambiguous language that appears in business contracts by. The ninth circuit reasoned that because the agreement was ambiguous on the issue of class arbitration, rather than silent, that ambiguity should be construed against the drafter of the arbitration agreement i. As a consequence, the parties do not intend that the presumptions of laws or rules relating to the interpretation of contracts against the drafter of.
To effectively accomplish this, a contract drafter needs to seek to understand principles of contract interpretation and contract construction. The party relying upon construing the contract against the drafter runs the risk that the courts will find a way to reconcile the contract clauses. Uniform premarital and marital agreements act, section 25. Such disagreement by the parties may be based on real confusion or an effort by a party to. Or better yet, the claim should simply be invalidated as indefinite, though our court has not seen fit to go there as yet. In a contract, an ambiguous term is construed against the. Njicle is extremely grateful for his efforts and perseverance. Plaintiff did not file a supporting certification confirming his understanding of the agreement. Buy drafting commercial agreements 2nd ed, by stuart cakebread, juliette levy. An ambiguous term is construed against the drafter and therefore favors staggs interpretation of the meaning of the term which is that the award consists of the amount before setoffs which exceeded the minimum prescribed by illinois law.
Williams research professor, professor of law, georgetown university law center. Views on how courts should interpret contracts vary widely. He doesnt seem to consider that a drafter might intend just the opposite, for example with a socalled knowledge rep. Judge plager argues that courts should begin to apply the contract doctrine of contra proferentem and construe ambiguous terms against the drafter i. No provision of this agreement or any related document will be construed against or interpreted to the disadvantage of any party hereto by any court or other governmental or judicial authority by reason of such party having or being deemed to have structured or drafted such provision. The supreme court has applied the rule of contra proferentem a doctrine that ambiguities in a contract are to be construed unfavorably against the drafter only after an attempt is made to determine the parties intent behind an ambiguous term, and only if a preponderance of the evidence does not prove the parties intent should the jury construe ambiguous terms against the drafter. Drafting around principles of interpretation adams on contract. The contra proferentem rule whereas ambiguity goes against. Supreme court confirms class arbitration may not proceed. This contract clause says that any ambiguous language in the contract shall be interpreted according to its fair meaning and not strictly for or against any party. Here is how ambiguities are treated under california law. In those situations in which the parties failed to so draft the agreement, the rules.
State of michigan court of appeals state bar of michigan. Amberlynn curry, the uniform premarital agreement act and its variations throughout the states, 23 j. Nov 10, 2001 under those circumstances, the party adversely impacted by the clause may lose the ability to have it construed against the drafter. Accordingly, this agreement has been drafted on the basis of the parties mutual contributions of language and the agreement is not to be construed against any party as being the drafter of this agreement. Agreement and plan of merger no construction against drafter. What california code states that the ambiguity will be. What is ambiguity in contract against drafter answers. Supreme court to further clarify class arbitration issues. Where a party drafted an agreement, to the extent there exists any ambiguity in the agreement, that ambiguity should be construed against the party that drafted the agreement. All cleaning s indemnification obligations depended on a judicial finding of negligence, omission, or conduct on all cleaning s part.
After considering the parties submissions, the court entered its order denying the motion. Are vagueambiguous contract provisions always construed. As such, any rule of interpretation or construction requiring that the language of this agreement or the exhibits be construed against the drafter is inapplicable to this agreement. This principle applies only when all of the other methods for resolving ambiguities prove unavailing. The 9th circuit said its possible to interpret the agreement in more than one way, and under california contract law, ambiguities must be interpreted against the party who drafted the agreement. The latin term contra proferentem translates as against the offerer and is used in law as a principle stating that where a contract contains an ambiguous term, that term should be interpreted against the party that proffered the term. An ambiguous term in a contract is to be construed against the drafter. Each party hereby acknowledges and agrees that each has been advised and encouraged by their respective legal counsel to. Ambiguous lease agreement rightfully construed against drafter in landlordtenant dispute july 14 2014 the court held that the trial court properly ruled in favor of the defendanttenant on the plaintifflandlords claim that it breached their lease agreement, and that it properly awarded case evaluation sanctions to the defendantcontractor.
For purposes of this agreement, both client and cbsw hereby waive any rule of construction that requires that ambiguities in this agreement including any schedule hereto be construed against the drafter. At times, the contract provides that the terms shall be interpreted according to the. Howard and mildred hamilton entered into a stock sale agreement to sell western sling and cable company western. Carl a schuberg, inc v kroger co, 1 mich app 310, 317. Contract construction and interpretation by courts jay. Under north carolina law ambiguities in a contract are construed against the drafter. This is particularly important if you draft the contract because ambiguities in a. The contra proferentem rule whereas ambiguity goes against the drafter or party that sought inclusion of the ambiguous term contract law, provincial offences, employment law, tort law and criminal law summary caruso legal services paralegal 289 271. Pursuant to longestablished new york law, if a contract was ambiguous because it did not state a term explicitly, then its terms must be strictly construed against the drafter. Finally, the majority addressed one of the two doctrines relied on by the california court. The principle of contra proferentem is a legal doctrine of contractual interpretation providing that ambiguous or conflicting terms within a contract should, generally, be construed against the party that drafted or proffered meaning put forward the agreement or demanded inclusion of the ambiguous terms. If, however, you have input in revising, rewording, changing, or amending a term within the agreement, the contract may be deemed mutually drafted by a court in the event the contract is breached. Agreement not to compete sample contracts and business forms.
The tenant invoked the rule that ambiguity in contracts is to be construed against the drafter of the contract, set forth in the restatement second of contracts, section 206, if the interpretation offered by the other party is reasonable. An ambiguity in a contract will be construed against the drafter. Beware of unclear language in construction contractsforms. It is agreed by and between the parties that this agreement shall be construed under and pursuant to the laws of the state of insert state, which state is and is intended to be the matrimonial domicile. Cinderella theatre co v united detroit theatres corp, 367 mich 424, 116 nw2d 825 1962. What is clear, however, is that in the face of this ambiguity, the agreement must be construed against spring lake, the drafter, and in favor of langley, the non drafter. This settlement agreement shall be treated as jointly drafted, and will not be construed against any party as the drafter.
677 4 1097 474 1135 1005 656 761 553 970 553 143 1525 1576 297 541 252 1186 770 907 1370 766 1023 771 591 573 374 764 1020 885 1429 267 1470 369 925 623 1229